From my buddy's latest substack... think it applies here for those that see no value in these argumentative threads:
In the earnest and sincere pursuit of knowledge and progress toward understanding, the value of opposing viewpoints cannot be overstated. It is through the clash of ideas, the confrontation of differing perspectives, and the robust exchange of opinions that society is able to grow and evolve.
Diversity of thought is recognized as a fundamental driver of innovation and critical thinking. By engaging with viewpoints that challenge our own, we are compelled to question our assumptions, reevaluate our beliefs, and strengthen our arguments. The presence of dissenting voices fosters intellectual rigor, encourages broader perspectives, and ultimately leads to more informed decision-making. Throughout history, Greek and Roman philosophers have emphasized the importance of open discourse and the practice of disagreement, recognizing that it is through the crucible of debate that the best-backed position can emerge.
The utility of debate was particularly cherished in the ancient Roman Senate, where the practice of argument for the sake of argument thrived. Prominent Greek and Roman writers such as Cicero, a renowned Roman statesman and philosopher, and Plato, the influential Greek philosopher, were advocates of this approach. Cicero, in his work "De Oratore," emphasized the value of differing viewpoints, arguing that through discussion and contention, the most accurate and persuasive arguments could be discerned. Plato, in his renowned dialogue "The Republic," portrayed Socrates engaging in rigorous debates to arrive at the truth, emphasizing that open discourse allows for the discovery of superior ideas. The Roman Senate, inspired by such teachings, embraced the culture of debate, welcoming dissenting voices and encouraging senators to present contrasting opinions in pursuit of the best course of action. This tradition of intellectual clash and dialogue in the Senate not only fortified the decision-making process but also exemplified the importance of respectful disagreement in a democratic society, where diverse perspectives are valued, and the strength of ideas is tested through rigorous debate.
Western Culture has a long history of a genuine appreciation for the value of open, rational discourse. True leaders value dissent among their ranks as a source of invaluable insight of many flavors.
popularrationalism.substack.com
