Oak Wilt? Something Else?

pheromone may be the wrong word....was thinking an odor or attractant such as emitted by ash in China that resists EAB. This is probably just the odor of photosynthate that attracts the beetles. The same with elm I guess.
Trees release "volatiles" that some insects are able to detect telling them the tree is injured. That is a very generic term because insect pheromones are also volatiles...but they are released by insects. Same idea, a volatile organic compound (VOC: Like the stuff they try to limit in paint, etc....) that is triggered by a certain event to elicit a certain response. So, yeah same idea as pheromones...but released by a tree instead of an insect. You already knew that!
 
Trees release "volatiles" that some insects are able to detect telling them the tree is injured. That is a very generic term because insect pheromones are also volatiles...but they are released by insects. Same idea, a volatile organic compound (VOC: Like the stuff they try to limit in paint, etc....) that is triggered by a certain event to elicit a certain response. So, yeah same idea as pheromones...but released by a tree instead of an insect. You already knew that!
Wonder what the Chinese ash'es pheromone is that repels (instead of sugar enticing) EAB since it is likely injury induced or maybe it is just airborn. I know scientists have tried to recreate it crossing their ash trees with ours but I think their ashes are just an ugly/common looking tree and the beauty of ours is lost in the cultivar?
 
Wonder what the Chinese ash'es pheromone is that repels (instead of sugar enticing) EAB since it is likely injury induced or maybe it is just airborn. I know scientists have tried to recreate it crossing their ash trees with ours but I think their ashes are just an ugly/common looking tree and the beauty of ours is lost in the cultivar?
I think those are questions that are still being researched.... The Forest service Lab in Delaware Ohio is doing some of that research. They have a greenhouse full of ash saplings that they tape eggs to and somebody gets to peel all of those trees to count and measure larvae.

Last I knew, the working theory was not that Chinese ash repelled EAB, rather they didn't release whatever it is that EAB is able to "smell" so trees aren't as easy for the bug to find.

If that is so, it's a little crazy that a bug is adapted to find something in a tree that it isn't exposed to for several thousand years...
 
Catching up on this one — good discussion. From central IL where oak wilt is established, the pruning-timing point is the one I'd underline for the OP: avoid pruning oaks from bud break through leaf drop (roughly April–October here). Nitidulid beetles vector the fungus to fresh wounds during that window, and that's how overland spread happens. If a storm forces your hand in summer, paint the wound immediately — that's the one case where wound dressing earns its keep, since it masks the volatiles the beetles home in on.

And +1 on lab confirmation before doing anything drastic. Sap seep and falling leaf clusters can be several things, and oak wilt management (trenching to break root grafts, removing sporulating trees before spring) is aggressive enough that you want certainty first.

We tell our Peoria customers the same thing every spring — our quick writeup on when to hold off on trimming, oak-wilt season included: https://treeremovalpeoriail.com/when-to-avoid-trimming-tree-branches-illinois/
 
View attachment 102399Red Oak in front yard, customer called and said it is dropping small clusters of leaves after the turn brown; sometimes quite a few fall at once, he says they're falling daily.

The leaves that are falling appear to be dying back like Bacterial Leaf Scorch, except it's the wrong time of year for BLS symptoms. The tree looks a little thin up top, but I can't get a good angle to see the top real well.

Also, I can see a few small cracks that appear to be leaking sap. I didn't get any decent photos of those, but did get some good photos of the fallen leaves and tried to zoom in on one patch of the leaves that are turning colors.

Oak Wilt has not been confirmed this far east in PA, but it's not too far away, so is it possible this could be the first confirmed case? Or is it (hopefully!) something else?View attachment 102400View attachment 102401
I AM quite familiar with BLS, and though those leaves look somewhat similar, that pattern of discoloration does not look like BLS... Especially the top photo.. Wee're in Philly suburbs with no reports of oak wilt... I feel kind of spoiled for being able to prune oaks any time ...
 
You ever figure this one out @Reach ? The tell for Oak Wilt: is the tree still alive 3.5 months later?
No never figured it out. The first one was removed a month after we looked at it, still living at the time but dropping leaf clusters. The other I haven't had time to look at again, I've just been too busy and they're not a paying customer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ATH

New threads New posts

Back
Top Bottom