Employee time off policy?

Evo

Been here much more than a while
Location
My Island, WA
Before I become more frustrated I’m finding the need to develop a clear time off policy for the employees. I’m in the feild less and less these days for general work to allow for solo jobs, reports, and other type of work.

There has been a habit forming where an employee will make a ‘time off request’ with the presumption it’s an automatic allowance. When I try to negotiate with date swapping such as “if you work Monday (normal non scheduled work day) I can make the request for Friday happen. This is met with “sorry but I can’t, I already bought the tickets”.
Obviously this isn’t a request but a demand and it’s not sitting well with me.

I’m considering a formal policy, where there is a minimum advance notice for time off and an annual cap of allowed time off. Such as ‘consecutive time off requests must be made a minimum of 30 days in advance. No presumption of allowance will be implied by making a request. Requests may be fully granted or partially, some date swapping may be necessary with regular non work days to accommodate the request.”

Or something like that.

Generally I’m booked 3-5 months out, and many of my clients have windows or other deadlines that need to be met.

I’m considering capping ‘vacation’ time to two work weeks per year, and obviously sick days or emergencies are a different matter. As part of this ‘demand of employment’ I’m considering offering 1 of the 2 weeks paid (average weekly payroll per past 12 months).

This is outside my normal management style but I’m being increasingly met with a dynamic that isn’t working for the business. Either I deny the request and the employee has to cash out of their pre purchased plans (obviously creating animosity) or I have to allow the time off which effects production and increases work loads of accommodation for the request.

What’s a reasonable policy? How much advanced notice? Max annual allowed time?

Also considering regular pre announced company days off (holidays etc) alongside time windows where there will be no approved time off when I know I’m regularly unable to accommodate requests. Such as no requests for time off October 1-15, month of November (except thanksgiving), March 15-25th and so on [random example]

How yall handle it?
FYI total crew of 3 (myself included) and very limited skilled workforce pool.
 
Last edited:
Addendum, also any thoughts on emergency job policies? Say there is a f-off storm on Friday night and I’m needing the crew to work through the weekend? How do you handle calling in on scheduled days off? What’s reasonable employer expectation?

Obviously this would be time and a half regardless of overtime.
 
As far as storm work It’s unusual for us to not know a head of time that some nice summer storms are going to pop off or opposite Ice. whether that drums up work is another story. I’ve worked where “on call” was offered x amount and or x hours to be “on call” on top of any hours worked with expected weather similar to snow plow operations. I think this was two fold, A make sure we had employees B make sure they were sober. We would have an on call sign up 48hrs in advance if no takers then it became boss discretion but typically money was enough of a motivator.
 
We offer employees five days of paid vacation and five days of paid sick time their first year, and we added a day of paid vacation for every year they've been with us.

To take a vacation day, you must request it at least a week in advance, and it is not a guarantee, though I work hard to make it as close to a guarantee as possible. Usually my guys are pretty good about giving advanced notice, especially if they want more than a day off. And sometimes I will tell them that they can't have that particular day, due to something that's on the schedule, but I will offer a different day that week, which is usually acceptable to all involved.

I think it is not unreasonable to require a 30 day notice if someone wants to take off more than two consecutive days. I believe that's what our handbook says, but I don't remember for sure because I haven't looked at the book in quite a while. I need to work on it this winter, and make some updates anyway.

Sick days can be used at any time of course, because they are for sicknesses.

I tell my employees that if there is a big storm, they are expected to be here, regardless of what they may have going on. That goes for the office lady as well, if we have a big storm somebody has to be available to answer the telephone. We had a whopper this summer, worst storm I've ever seen, so I called in my retired mother to sit at the telephone as well because we had a month worth of phone calls in two days. Usually, I try to be reasonable if someone has a valid reason they are not available. If it's not a major storm, just a bit of storm damage, I will call around to see if I can put a decent sized volunteer crew together before I start telling people they must show up. I explain before I hire people that they are expected to show up for big storms, and could have to work any or all hours when there is a storm. That is part of life in the tree industry.
 
We offer employees five days of paid vacation and five days of paid sick time their first year, and we added a day of paid vacation for every year they've been with us.

To take a vacation day, you must request it at least a week in advance, and it is not a guarantee, though I work hard to make it as close to a guarantee as possible. Usually my guys are pretty good about giving advanced notice, especially if they want more than a day off. And sometimes I will tell them that they can't have that particular day, due to something that's on the schedule, but I will offer a different day that week, which is usually acceptable to all involved.

I think it is not unreasonable to require a 30 day notice if someone wants to take off more than two consecutive days. I believe that's what our handbook says, but I don't remember for sure because I haven't looked at the book in quite a while. I need to work on it this winter, and make some updates anyway.

Sick days can be used at any time of course, because they are for sicknesses.

I tell my employees that if there is a big storm, they are expected to be here, regardless of what they may have going on. That goes for the office lady as well, if we have a big storm somebody has to be available to answer the telephone. We had a whopper this summer, worst storm I've ever seen, so I called in my retired mother to sit at the telephone as well because we had a month worth of phone calls in two days. Usually, I try to be reasonable if someone has a valid reason they are not available. If it's not a major storm, just a bit of storm damage, I will call around to see if I can put a decent sized volunteer crew together before I start telling people they must show up. I explain before I hire people that they are expected to show up for big storms, and could have to work any or all hours when there is a storm. That is part of life in the tree industry.
Thanks! I’m simply looking for a baseline point of reference and this is incredibly helpful.

Do you accommodate time off requests that accrue beyond the five day paid cut off?

I’m all about being super flexible but finding I need some formal boundaries as a baseline. For myself and the employees.

Your storm work is the same with any company I ever worked for too..
 
...... I explain before I hire people that they are expected to show up for big storms, and could have to work any or all hours when there is a storm. That is part of life in the tree industry.
That's key. If they are taking the job, that's an expectation.

I don't have an official policy...I've just told guys let me know as soon as you know. A past employee would show up and say "I need to be home by 2:30 today". OK...we are working 30 minutes away in the opposite direction. And it's an all day job. If you told me ahead we could have planned accordingly. You can drive your own vehicle to the job site and off the clock when you leave. He is gone... mutual parting of ways. Nobody else has been difficult to work with. They let me know. Almost always ask "would it be OK if I take off Monday in 3 weeks".

I add vacation each pay check such that they get 2 weeks per year. Nobody has been with me long enough to earn more vacation time yet.

I'll let them flex to 4 tens periodically if they want. Current full time guy is super flexible. Doesn't mind if we go long. I try to cut him loose as soon as possible on days we are done with things early to keep hours fair.

I've joked if an employee makes us write a policy I'm going to name it after them. "We never had a firm vacation policy because it works for everyone. Now we need 30 days notice. We'll call this the George Policy. Thank George for the new requirements. If we need to talk to Phil about phone use again, we'll have a Phil Policy completly banning any phone use on job sites."
 
That's key. If they are taking the job, that's an expectation.

I don't have an official policy...I've just told guys let me know as soon as you know. A past employee would show up and say "I need to be home by 2:30 today". OK...we are working 30 minutes away in the opposite direction. And it's an all day job. If you told me ahead we could have planned accordingly. You can drive your own vehicle to the job site and off the clock when you leave. He is gone... mutual parting of ways. Nobody else has been difficult to work with. They let me know. Almost always ask "would it be OK if I take off Monday in 3 weeks".

I add vacation each pay check such that they get 2 weeks per year. Nobody has been with me long enough to earn more vacation time yet.

I'll let them flex to 4 tens periodically if they want. Current full time guy is super flexible. Doesn't mind if we go long. I try to cut him loose as soon as possible on days we are done with things early to keep hours fair.

I've joked if an employee makes us write a policy I'm going to name it after them. "We never had a firm vacation policy because it works for everyone. Now we need 30 days notice. We'll call this the George Policy. Thank George for the new requirements. If we need to talk to Phil about phone use again, we'll have a Phil Policy completly banning any phone use on job sites."
Much like you I’m adverse to ‘policy’ and have always found accommodations like you mentioned about driving your own car and clocking off..
anything I come up with on paper is the framework, which can be bent as needed.

This is the first batch of employees that I have had for this long.. 5 years in January, I think my looser approach has allowed for too much flexibility in expectations.
 
I think Reach and ATH have hit the key point here — setting the expectation before someone starts makes all the difference. If storm cover and the notice periods are part of the conversation at hiring, it feels less like a new rule and more like part of the job.

For a crew of three, your idea of a written framework that can still bend a little sounds sensible. A week for a day or two, and thirty days for anything longer, gives you time to move clients around, and it also gives the employee a clear answer instead of having to guess. Keeping sick days and genuine emergencies separate from planned holiday seems important too, so nobody feels they have to choose between the two.

I would also write the company days off down in the same place, so everyone can plan around them at the start of the year. Clear on paper, flexible in practice — that seems like a fair balance.
 
Thanks! I’m simply looking for a baseline point of reference and this is incredibly helpful.

Do you accommodate time off requests that accrue beyond the five day paid cut off?

I’m all about being super flexible but finding I need some formal boundaries as a baseline. For myself and the employees.

Your storm work is the same with any company I ever worked for too..
Yes, I will let employees take off days beyond the paid time off limit, within reason. If you have lousy reasons, and you want to keep taking days off, you are probably going to find yourself working elsewhere but if you have a reasonable request we will let you take the day off, we just won't pay you for it.
 
There’s a trend in America, in my opinion, that if you work for an employer, said employer has some ownership rights of your time. I think as time goes on, we as Americans, forget how important freedoms are intrinsically. I believe two parties, the employer and the employed, should work together to meet an understanding that benefits both parities with respect to one another. This doesn’t work if one of those parties betrays the respect part of this agreement. Ie: Requesting a day of 12 hours in advance, when the requester knew about the event 2 weeks ago. Dictating a number of days off to a max to retain employment is counterintuitive. We should only work to support our families in a way that brings us as much enjoyment as humanly possible. Wealth is fleeting and should be unimportant in this equation. I firmly believe that if employees are respected, and truly valued in understanding that their free time is treated as theirs, actually their time is treated theirs entirely, the employee will not only give you the time you need, but will stay with you for a longer period of time. Time is given to us as employers as a trade for the ability to live in this world with the necessities…we should never forget that. Time is one thing God gave us that we can never ever get back. I’m sure most of you had this thought as you went into business for yourself, I sure did. Nothing upsets an employee more than being undervalued or disrespected by forgetting about who owns their time…them.

I also believe that not every employee will treat this partnership with respect, and at that point, the shoe no longer fits…

Just a thought on how I’ve seen greed affect our industry among others.

Edit: That all being said: businesses and charities are different for a reason. Both parties must agree on a minimum time applicable to receive benefits and PTO. For example a minimum of 32hours x 52 weeks to maintain employer paid health and dental. If you offer PTO and they exhaust it, well it’s their time, they just aren’t paid for it because technically that check is yours until the work for pay trade is completed in whatever terms that means for you and them.
 
Last edited:
Our employees are paid salary if they need to leave early then they get paid hourly that day and only allowed once a month.

We start at 7:30 and usually off by 1:30 normally sometimes even by 11:00 once in a while 3:30 if longer then compensated for their time.

We also do double days usually at least three times a month where the crew gets paid for two days and still normally off by 4:00 which technically makes the hours of two days.

We allow one day off per month also for holidays also for special occasions, but not to make it a routine. No time off paid but Christmas bonuses but have to be employed at least one year or prorated.

I try I be lenient, but seems like the new guy always tries to take advantage of.
 
There’s a trend in America, in my opinion, that if you work for an employer, said employer has some ownership rights of your time. ...
I agree with about everything else you said except I question the opening sentence a little.

"Trend" implies this is something relatively new or a shift in tendency. That's where I disagree. I think the trend is fewer employers treating their employees as such. But also more employees expecting they can do whatever they want whenever they want and blaming/shaming the employer when they don't get their way.

I get a lot of that from talking to a couple friends who work in factory settings. But also reading other employer/employee relationship information/articles, etc... Even with better pay and more flexible scheduling they struggle to find workers to show up. Heck, my wife coordinates volunteers for a children's program at church and it's amazing how many treat it as "something better came up so I cannot be there tomorrow morning". Their choice, but backing out of a commitmentakes life difficult for a lot of other people.

Yes, there are still very inflexible employers. But I think the trend is low commitment/lack of self discipline/laziness on behalf of the employees. Because there are pretty widespread labor shortages, employers are kinda forced to deal with it or run short handed. I guess I'd rather run short handed and just know what we have than plan around someone being there and they flake out.
 
Before I become more frustrated I’m finding the need to develop a clear time off policy for the employees. I’m in the feild less and less these days for general work to allow for solo jobs, reports, and other type of work.

There has been a habit forming where an employee will make a ‘time off request’ with the presumption it’s an automatic allowance. When I try to negotiate with date swapping such as “if you work Monday (normal non scheduled work day) I can make the request for Friday happen. This is met with “sorry but I can’t, I already bought the tickets”.
Obviously this isn’t a request but a demand and it’s not sitting well with me.

I’m considering a formal policy, where there is a minimum advance notice for time off and an annual cap of allowed time off. Such as ‘consecutive time off requests must be made a minimum of 30 days in advance. No presumption of allowance will be implied by making a request. Requests may be fully granted or partially, some date swapping may be necessary with regular non work days to accommodate the request.”

Or something like that.

Generally I’m booked 3-5 months out, and many of my clients have windows or other deadlines that need to be met.

I’m considering capping ‘vacation’ time to two work weeks per year, and obviously sick days or emergencies are a different matter. As part of this ‘demand of employment’ I’m considering offering 1 of the 2 weeks paid (average weekly payroll per past 12 months).

This is outside my normal management style but I’m being increasingly met with a dynamic that isn’t working for the business. Either I deny the request and the employee has to cash out of their pre purchased plans (obviously creating animosity) or I have to allow the time off which effects production and increases work loads of accommodation for the request.

What’s a reasonable policy? How much advanced notice? Max annual allowed time?

Also considering regular pre announced company days off (holidays etc) alongside time windows where there will be no approved time off when I know I’m regularly unable to accommodate requests. Such as no requests for time off October 1-15, month of November (except thanksgiving), March 15-25th and so on [random example]

How yall handle it?
FYI total crew of 3 (myself included) and very limited skilled workforce pool.
I'm an employee and I will say that new rules restricting previous freedoms are worse than rules explained on hiring. Bad for morale. If you've got 2 people that want to work for you for 5 years straight you've probably been doing a lot right, so congratulations. Will say the way you talk about your employees time sounds a little like you don't respect my time outside of work and I probably wouldn't want to work for you. I think it may be a limitation of having a 3 person production crew though. If any of our employees need to get to appointments/family/friend commitments after work for something that came up suddenly, we just tell them to bring their personal vehicle and we'll make due without them when that time comes. As a crew lead I'll shoo people off the jobsite when the time comes for people to go get back to whatever the commitment was. We also run 2 crews and have at least 3 people per crew which allows for more wiggle room like that. But the flexibility is huge and why I have zero plans of looking for work elsewhere.

We get 2 weeks PTO, no sick days, standard holidays, and no formal policy on days in a row needing x amount of days ahead of time for request. If my bosses instituted that I would be annoyed but would be understanding since they are generally very good to us in most ways and are relatively flexible since we all have good relationships. We also only put things on the schedule like 1.5 weeks out generally unless there's specific requests or circumstances (line drops/crane rentals).
 
I'm an employee and I will say that new rules restricting previous freedoms are worse than rules explained on hiring. Bad for morale. If you've got 2 people that want to work for you for 5 years straight you've probably been doing a lot right, so congratulations. Will say the way you talk about your employees time sounds a little like you don't respect my time outside of work and I probably wouldn't want to work for you. I think it may be a limitation of having a 3 person production crew though. If any of our employees need to get to appointments/family/friend commitments after work for something that came up suddenly, we just tell them to bring their personal vehicle and we'll make due without them when that time comes. As a crew lead I'll shoo people off the jobsite when the time comes for people to go get back to whatever the commitment was. We also run 2 crews and have at least 3 people per crew which allows for more wiggle room like that. But the flexibility is huge and why I have zero plans of looking for work elsewhere.

We get 2 weeks PTO, no sick days, standard holidays, and no formal policy on days in a row needing x amount of days ahead of time for request. If my bosses instituted that I would be annoyed but would be understanding since they are generally very good to us in most ways and are relatively flexible since we all have good relationships. We also only put things on the schedule like 1.5 weeks out generally unless there's specific requests or circumstances (line drops/crane rentals).
So if 4 guys call tomorrow morning and said we're taking the next 5 days off that'd be cool with everyone?

I know that's an extreme example...but that's why policies are sometimes needed. I get the impression @Evo is flexible. But flexibility is a LOT easier with planning.

Speaking for myself I have no problem working around advance notice time off - whether PTO, unpaid if they want, or we'll flex the schedule so they can take it off without using PTO or losing hours for the week. But I cannot tell 3 clients tomorrow morning that we are not keeping out commitment to them to be there tomorrow. If that happens too often then nobody is working before long.
 
As an employee, I understand that a lack of planning on my part doesn't constitute an emergency for my employer or co-workers. I have never been told no when I needed to leave suddenly for a legit nobody-else-but-me-can-handle-this kind of emergency, but those are rare, as they should be. If you have those kinds of emergencies more than two, maybe three times a year, they cease to be as legit, and start slipping back into the 'poor planning' category.

I understand @Maplegeddon213 , that it would feel a bit insulting to get a strict new policy after five years of things seemingly working fine, but I have been an employer and a manager too, and having people not give you at least a week heads up is bullshit, and goes back to 'lack of planning'; That's your problem, not mine. Every teacher I had in school had the same policy, so unless you had a wildly different experience growing up in this country, I don't know where you would have gotten confused about that part of the social contract.

As a worker, I hate when somebody bails on work last minute, and I have to do 25-35% more work for the same pay to get things finished on time, and as an employer/manager, It really fucks the whole schedule I spent hours making when/if your absence means we don't finish a one day job on the day, and then we have to figure out scheduling that into an already busy schedule.

Your actions have consequences, plain and simple. All this is a two way deal.
 

New threads New posts

Back
Top Bottom