RBJtree
Branched out member
- Location
- Pittsburgh
One of my employees recently cut the sides on a large oak because he thought the bar was too short. It was not near any targets, but we were trying to not do damage to surrounding trees and keep the debris in a certain area. The tree had a back lean and they were pulling with a rope redirected by a block to a truck. I wasn't there when they pulled the tree, but the stump told the story. The center was rotten and he cut the sides where the only good hinge wood was. The tree fell over sideways when the hinge broke prematurely. No harm done, but if a guy does it then, what would make me think he isn't going to do it when it matters? It blows my freakin mind. It seems like common sense to me. I swear my guy knows better and thats why I let him be in the position he was in. He helped teach me to climb 17 years ago for god sakes!
The op's tree went where it was supposed to go, but cutting the sides was an unnecessary risk that could have caused a premature hinge failure and the reason for cutting away some of the hinge wasn't valid in my opinion. It is my suggestion to not trim the sides on a rotten tree.
The op's tree went where it was supposed to go, but cutting the sides was an unnecessary risk that could have caused a premature hinge failure and the reason for cutting away some of the hinge wasn't valid in my opinion. It is my suggestion to not trim the sides on a rotten tree.
