New article up ....

I've just finished reading the article, and must say I'm a bit surprised that you would choose to publish an article touting the benefits of a technique that is is clearly against written and accepted industry safety standards. Yes, the standards allow for exceptions to be made, but I'm sure it wasn't the intent of those who drafted these standards to excuse casual and habituated one handed cutting. I understand wanting to spark conversation, and assume that was the purpose of sharing this article. I work for a municipality that employs around twenty five arborists, of these, I am the only one who does not habitually one hand a saw. In the last eight years there have been three or four accidents directly attributable to the technique, and at least half of the guys have undergone shoulder surgery, or suffer chronic pain most likely caused by the poor ergonomics inherent to one handing. In the end it's your body you're risking. There is almost always another way to get the job done. Make your own decisions, but for me the purported "benefits " just don't add up in the long run.
 
Garbage, I could say so much but why promote poor technique and thereby denigrate the "professionalism" of arborists.
 
A round of abstinence then Boom!
(of homepage articles - just to be clear)

This is a doozie. Looking forward to finishing this. It's more than a few scrolls on my mobile and I want to read all the way through. Thus far, I'm enjoying and appreciating a balanced approach.
 
@mrtree No disrespect but let's leave the "I'm right and your wrong, idiot" attitude at your end of the keyboard.

I like the article, thanks for posting Mark. Thank you to the author. Hope everyone can keep from saying something insulting about him because of content, I'm sure he spent some time writing this article, it's appreciated.
 
Well I am right in this case. If the saw manuals say not to operate one-handed and in the author's case the H&S laws say not to do it, why promote it? The same content, by the same author, has appeared in Arbclimber Magazine. No matter how much you want to tell a lie it does not make it true.

The article is an excellent example of the superman mentality within arboriculture that makes no sense to a single H&S professional. The response "I know how to do it" does not cut it. Anybody that wants to one-hand a saw can do it but please do not pretend that you are doing it for any reason other than arrogance.
 
There are a few other reasons; haste, laziness, shortsightedness, denial…..

The problem as I see it is, using the one-handed technique becomes the norm in situations where the risk outweigh the advantages. guys limbing on the ground or the blocking scenario where the left hand is used to push the piece off while the saw is still engaged in cutting.
Steve, said it best, use it safely. That means think it through. The opening of the article shows a picture that IME, is a poor example that comes rife with more risks than had the climber spent a bit more time thinking through their action plan instead of extending out and overhead to make a cut where their body is in line with the saw.

While the article may be well written and present the topic reasonably articulately it still ends up in the minds of those that abuse the technique as justification for always using it.
 
...do not pretend that you are doing it for any reason other than arrogance.

So, then... nobody ever one-handed a tophandle saw because they were lazy, or stupid, or ignorant of the consequences, or to speed up their production, or because they were better with a saw than they were with climbing half dead, rotting trees, or because they felt the risk of kickback was one hell of a lot lower than the risk of the limb hitting them, or because they felt they could not get a stable work position without holding onto something... absolutely none of these things is even remotely possible or ever occurs.

It's always about arrogance.

I see.
 
Hi i'm steve and I one hand my saw. I don't always one hand but when I do I have a reason. It's my reason and I own it as well as the consequences. I will not tell you i'm rite if you don't tell me i'm wrong. I don't feel justified by the article but I can see how some may. Nor do I consider myself even remotely arrogant. I'm actually a pretty humble dude
 
Well I am right in this case. If the saw manuals say not to operate one-handed and in the author's case the H&S laws say not to do it, why promote it? The same content, by the same author, has appeared in Arbclimber Magazine. No matter how much you want to tell a lie it does not make it true.

The article is an excellent example of the superman mentality within arboriculture that makes no sense to a single H&S professional. The response "I know how to do it" does not cut it. Anybody that wants to one-hand a saw can do it but please do not pretend that you are doing it for any reason other than arrogance.
Wow, what irony in the arrogance of this comment. ^^^
Snore... postmortem equine flagellation is still kicking …
 
Yes arrogance because I do know

But Yes we are beating a dead horse because arborists will never learn as an industry.
 

New threads New posts

Back
Top Bottom