Re: Dangerous Technique Alert!!!2
Frans, I know your post was sarcasm. Here is are some non-sarcastic reasons to participate however, so that those that don't realize your sarcasm can take away some good stuff. (you never know who is reading, there are a lot of non-professional viewers). Therefore, unambiguity is important.
Let me begin:
ahhemm..........
....pause.........
International Arborist Community:
Lets rally here and come up with some good reasons why a climbing competition should continue.
I will speak from my personal experience:
In a tree, time is not always something that we have an unlimited supply of.
ie: Being tied in at 100+ feet and having abrupt storm development create a need for a quick descent and break down of gear.
ie: having an injured climber that needs to be rescued as quickly as possible.
ie: having a dinner date at 7pm, and its 5:00, and you want to "get er done....but safely....while the home owners watch from the road" and you still have a couple massive leads to lower out before driving the chipper truck home.
ie: having only so much energy in a day to "burn" and take in, and wanting to work as efficiently and quickly as is possible under safe methods.
ie: a need for safe work practices to be learned and employed at all times, under the watchful eye of a panel of judges that will disqualify the climber if unsafe practices are employed.
Climbing competitions have only made me a safer climber. A better climber. A more aware climber. A more knowledgeable climber because I am sharing my methods with other progressive climbers in competition.
Climbing in competitions also helps the climber overcome a sense of "peer pressure" that is mentioned in the argument against climbing competitions. Peer pressure is all in the imagination. Are your peers really pressuring you? I disagree. I get support from the competitors in all the climbing competitions I have participated in. I get support from the crowd that gathers out of interest in the events. This "pressure" that you term is not unlike the "pressure" that can also be felt when actually performing on a job, when just as much is at stake. As far as I am concerned, it's all the same.
Usually the local community gathers out of interest. Nobody is there to see anybody fall out of a tree. They don't leave unsatisfied if there are no casualties. I personally haven't witnessed any casualties in the yearly competitions I have attended since 2001.
I haven't even heard of any injuries. I don't ask about them either. I don't dwell on that. I have heard about a lot more casualties from bad judgement and unsafe work practices out in the work place however. Accidents that could have been preventable if a climber may have practiced under a bit of pressure in order to prepare for a situation that called for a bit more speed than what he/she may normally operate under.
I look at the climbing competitions as training. Just like in the work place, you do not want to go beyond your capabilities. That's bad judgement. You want to push your capabilities to new levels. What other place to do it than under the safety of a controlled environment such as an ISA sponsored tree climbing championship.
Do you offer a better alternative at a reasonable fee? Please let everyone know so that we can sign up.
I don't see anyone at the climbing competitions that doesn't belong there. It's because the trees don't lie. They only tell the truth. The climbers that show up have a good respect for gravity, the tree, and self. They usually show up in one piece, and leave a bit more intact somehow. I can say that from my personal experience.
Climbing at a competitive level is something that I was guided to from an inner compass. I didn't do it until I was ready. It's a personal choice. Nobody is making anyone compete.
I must ask you Frans, if you have ever competed before? You don't get punished for coming in last place. Sometimes you even get a prize if its your first time. There is a lot of support there. A lot of comradery.
You posting doesn't sound to be from first hand experience. Re-think this philosophy.
Do fireman need to speed around the city in training runs all the time? Why do they do that! It's dangerous to the community. Why don't they just wait for a fire before having to go so fast in there trucks. Everything was safer and quieter when they were in their fire station playing poker and washing their trucks.
Do police officers need to fire so many shots at the firing range in rapid succession? I mean, really? It's so loud, wastes so many bullets. Smells up the air, its really dangerous to them. Their are accidents in the firing range where bullet casing burn people and guns backfire. People lose there hearing. How often do they have to unload a mag, and re-load and unload another in less than a minute with accuracy?
How about the military! Damn. Could they just stop buzzing me with fighter jets when I am peacefully pruning out a canopy! Nothing like a little afterburner residue to seal up all the pruning cuts! Plus, its unsafe. Do they have to practice bombing runs in Downtown Atlanta? Can't they fly a little slower? I mean, 700 miles an hour? Come on. That's too fast. They are putting us in danger. Can't they just wait until there is a real threat, save the fuel, and just jump in the jet when its time to go drop some bombs and then fly real fast? It scares the #$%& out of me to here a sonic boom coming up from behind me while making a cut. I can't say any more. Please, USAF, fire a warning shot so I know your coming. After all, we do share the same airspace. As climbers, maybe we should begin filing flight plans prior to our climbs. Yeah, that would solve it.
There is a work pace that is considered "safe" and one that is "unsafe". Sometimes one needs to push their comfort zone to get "safe" not fast.
The climbing competitions are not just about "speed". Not at all. Its primarily about finess. There is a time "limit" which is reasonable for the events. The competitors don't show up and miraculously climb 3 times as fast as they normally do. I have never witnessed that.
They show up and do what they do. That's how it works. You climb that way at work, you get more done, under safe methodology. You show up, you compete. You compare yourself to other climbers, you learn new skills, like how to get a throwball maneuvered into a crotch. That's finess. Not necessarily careless abandonment of safety in the name of speed.
I see more safety at competitions than I witness with most non-competitive climbers. Why? Because they haven't had to lose all the points of an event for have their safety glasses fall off, or having their hand saw fall out of their sheath. Imagine what could happen if that saw fell on you? What if it was a power saw? I have seen that happen several times.....due to improperly securing the lanierd.
Arbormaster training is something that you may want to pursue, and then to push yourself to a new level of climbing start competing. This is when a higher level of the self-awareness really takes place. You got no choice.
Plus, if you have a competitive spirit, then it satisfies that. It is called the "tree climbing competition" isn't it? It isn't the "tree climbers picnic" although the food is usually there also.
Hopefully we will see you out at the next competition Frans. I recommend it. Bring a chair and some sun block, sponsor a couple of your climbers and go have fun. That's what its all about.