Article on America's Most Dangerous Jobs

Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

Bureau of Labor Statisitcs 2004 data released on Friday. Loggers top the list. Not sure if that includes all tree workers. Perhaps worth some reflection though...

http://money.cnn.com/2005/08/26/pf/jobs_jeopardy/index.htm

Here's some of the text:
Construction workers had 9 percent more fatalities. Of these, roofers recorded 94 deaths, a sharp increase from the 55 they incurred the year before.

The highest rates of fatal injuries -- the most per worker employed -- occurred among loggers, pilots, and fishermen.

Loggers recorded 85 fatalities in 2004, a rate of 92.4 deaths for every 100,000 workers, more than 22 times the rate among all workers. Loggers deal with tremendous weights when they fell trees and it's not always possible to know exactly where a tree will fall or when. Too, they often work on steep hillsides, in poor weather, and in a hurry.

Aircraft pilots matched that death rate of 92.4 and 109 of them died on the job. Many of these were in the general aviation category, small aircraft manned by bush pilots, air-taxi pilots, and crop-dusters. Their equipment can be old and the maintenance less stringent than among the big airlines, adding to the danger.

Rank, Occupation, Death rate/100,000, Total deaths

1, Logging workers, 92.4, 85
2, Aircraft pilots, 92.4, 109
3, Fishing workers, 86.4, 38
4, Steel workers, 7.0, 31
5, Refuse collectors, 43.2, 35
6, Farmers ranchers, 37.5, 307
7, Roofers, 34.9, 94
8, Electrical linemen, 30.0, 36
9, Truck drivers, 27.6, 905
10,Taxi drivers, 24.2, 67
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

Interesting.

Would anybody know if there are any recorded statistics on types of injuries arborists sustain? eg Chainsaw wounnds and to what part of the anatomy are most common?

Cheers Davo.
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

chainsaw injuries are most common to left hand I am told. problem seems to be that arborist type work is lumped with logging so the stats are hard to seperate.
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

Thanks Mark i would appreciate that.

Jimmyq, i went to see a local arborist the other day and noticed two stitches and about an inch and a half scar further up on the left arm of a young bloke he has working for him. I had to ask how, which lead to my assumptions - the chainsaw - one nic from running saw and one from over eager sharpening. Further chat revealed he is climbing - What kind of harness are you have? ..'a black one' was the answer. What type of acender are you using? ..'whats that?'
he replied. Unreal hey?

Cheers Davo.
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

[ QUOTE ]
chainsaw injuries are most common to left hand I am told. problem seems to be that arborist type work is lumped with logging so the stats are hard to seperate.

[/ QUOTE ]

Is this true? I cannot find anything that says that is the case. I noticed that roofers are not mixed in with general construction workers, so I would assume that arborists are not included in the logging industry. If you're talking about chainsaw statistics, then I agree it's all one big happy (dangerous) family, but as for the study of dangerous jobs, I'm not sure that is the case.
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

I think I recall John Ball saying, that arborist would rank about fifth on the list if they were counted seperate. But we are counted in with landscapers, so it brings the number of fatalitys pre 100,000 down.
-
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

Joelogger. as far as I have been told, arborist work is lumped with loggers for WCB around here. I am insured as a landscaper with "some tree pruning" in my description of duties. my WCB percentage is 3.5% or so, arborist and logger is about 13%. I havent seen seperate stats for the two different professions as yet. As for chainsaw inuries, I am just mentioning that which I have discussed with my local industry contacts.
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

This is long, but I hope its worth the read (and the time spent writing).

JimmyQ wrote:

[ QUOTE ]
as far as I have been told, arborist work is lumped with loggers for WCB around here.

[/ QUOTE ]

Jimyq:

You are in BC--British Columbia?? Arborists may be lumped with loggers in Canada, but in the U.S. arborists fall under Landscape and Horticulture.

CNNMoney published a report in October, 2003 that was similar to the one in the link in the first post of this thread. John Ball and Shane Vosberg referenced that (the 2003 report) in an article that was published in Arborist News magazine in April 2004. Ball and Vosberg stated:

"The federal government does not identify arborists as an entirely separate category for reporting occupational fatalities. Arborists are included for statistical purposes within the industry group Landscape and Horticultural Services, which includes lawn care workers, landscape gardeners, and landscape architects and designers, among others...If arborists are separated from this group, their fatality rate for 2003 was 39.5 fatalities per 100,000. That ranking places arborists as number five on the list of the most dangerous jobs in the United States. Some years we have been much higher in the rankings..."

(John Ball and Shane Vosberg, 'Tree Worker Safety: Which Accidents Occur in Our Industry?' Arborist News, April 2004).


UpTopDownUnder wrote:

[ QUOTE ]
Would anybody know if there are any recorded statistics on types of injuries arborists sustain? eg Chainsaw wounnds and to what part of the anatomy are most common?

[/ QUOTE ]

The article referenced above breaks down the types of <u>fatal</u> injuries sustained by arborists, but not all injuries. That would be difficult to track. This past summer I was involved in a round table discussion on emergency response. John Ball was also one of the participants and we discussed some of the data that he has been investigating. It seems that the number of injuries reported by OSHA may be far below what actually occurs. /forum/images/graemlins/frown.gif

I have numbers on chain saw injuries supplied by the U.S. Consumer product safety Commission report on Chain Saw Accidents for 1989. (I have more recent data (1998?)in my files at work, and the numbers are just slightly lower than these. If anyone wishes, I can dredge up those numbers as well.)

Accident Location and Frequency as Related to Chain Saw Use:

Head and Face: 3,091

Upper Body: 1,735

Hand Area: 14,381

Upper Leg, Knee, Lower Leg: 15,253

Foot Area: 2,817

TOTAL INJURIES: 37,277 /forum/images/graemlins/crazy.gif

These numbers are accompanied by the silhouette of a man with dots on his body to provide a visual idea of the areas that sustain the most injuries. Although the above figures show that there were over 14,000 injuries to the 'Hand Area', there are no dots on the right hand. This is presumably because the right hand is holding the throttle of the chain saw. The left hand is cut because the saw operator holds up the left hand to protect themself when the saw kicks back at them. There are some dots on the right upper body.

Although I believe that there are times when a trained worker may a use a saw with one hand, virtually all of the 'Hand Area' injuries, and probably some of the 'Head and Face', Upper Body', and possibly even the 'Foot Area' injuries could have been prevented if the operator had had two hands on the saw. This assumes that the saw was equipped with a functioning chain brake, but the lack of a functioning chain brake may also have been part of the reason for the injury.

If operators had worn chain saw chaps, then all or most of the 'Upper Leg, Knee, Lower Leg' injuries could have been prevented or reduced in severity.

Training and PPE could make a world of difference in the number and severity of these injuries.
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

Here are the 1989 numbers for chain saw injuries (copied from my post above), then the numbers for chain saw injuries in 1998:


1989:

Accident Location and Frequency as Related to Chain Saw Use:

Head and Face: 3,091

Upper Body: 1,735

Hand Area: 14,381

Upper Leg, Knee, Lower Leg: 15,253

Foot Area: 2,817

TOTAL CHAIN SAW INJURIES FOR 1989: 37,277



1998 (note that the categories are slightly different):

Head injuries: 2,955

Upper Body: 927

Arms and hands: 13,620

Other Areas: 19

Leg Injuries: 13,683

Foot Injuries: 1,954

TOTAL CHAINSAW INJURIES FOR 1998; 33,158


That's a drop of 4,119 injuries, or about 11% in the nine years from 1989 - 1998. It's interesting that the highest number of injuries still occur to the same two general parts of the body, the hands/arms and hands, and the upper leg, knee, lower leg/leg.

Training, proper technique, and PPE could have a tremendous impact on these numbers.
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

I wonder what % of those saw injuries are from the local lawn guy, who thought he could make an exta buck, by picking up a saw after a storm.
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

Thanks Mahk for your effort.

That is pretty much what i was hoping for - the stats that is, on location of injuries.

Regards Davo.

Crikey that avatar i created turned out to be a monster!
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

An aboriginal ceremonial dress shield?
 
Re: Article on America\'s Most Dangerous Jobs

It is a Sand Mandala created by Tibetan monks. Mandala is a Sanskrit word for circle. Mandala's are symbols of the universe and its energy. The monks create Mandalas to remind us of the cycle of life and death. For one week (for this particular one) they carefully insert coloured sand by rubbing brass funnels (like a stretched ice cream cone) which are filled with the sand. They make different Mandalas and each one has many layers of meaning according to their philosophy. There is a ceremony at the end where the mandala is 'destroyed' which signifies the law of impernanence - or death. The sand is the returned to the earth and given out to people who are there at the of the final ceremony.

Cheers Davo.
 

New threads New posts

Back
Top Bottom