The AR requirement has always been there, and I don't think "good enough" should be good enough. when we start trying to bend the rules to obtain certifications it takes alot of credibility out of the cert. process.
ISA only calls for "A.R. Training", not any proof of proficiency in performing AR. It would be easy for anyone to set up a mock AR one time and then have boss or self sign off, but do you actually practice AR once a month? once a year? for that matter why even do the AR, why not just sign the paper saying you did it? You've got to be honest with yourself before you can be honest with everyone else.
TCI's EHAP program has an AR element with outside verifyer. TCC could work if you acually completed the AR event, how many guys never even make it to the victim or up the tree before time runs out? is this AR tanining? sure. Is it AR proficient? definitely not. Also check out ACRT for outside verification.
Zeke, this rant is not aimed specifically at you, you just set up the shot, hope I score.