Comps are a blessing and a curse in my mind. I totally understand and agree with the ways it advances efficiencies and knowledge. But I just disagree with a speed factor being a major component to any skills competition that involves potential for catastrophic injury when something goes wrong. The current comp format encourages speed. It's one of the only judging criteria that isn't subjective. You're either faster than everyone or you're not. It will inherently lead to accidents in an already accident prone task. Think the ISA will put together a document that catalogs all the accidents and injuries at the various chapter comps over the years? I've heard plenty of stories but would like to see what the data actually says.
In any case, different strokes for different folks and variety is the spice of life. I like options and I'm glad I've found a combo of harness, climb line, and friction device that makes me comfortable so I can focus on the work.