Gentleman- good discussion. A couple of thoughts from the employer's perspective:
1. Certification is an indication of a certain amount of commitment to the industry. It does take a little bit of effort to pass the test. Does it guarantee that someone is a good arborist- absolutely not!
When I post job openings everybody that knows what a tree is and has seen a chainsaw applies and tells you how interested they are about learning a new trade. I look for people that have taken some initiative in progressing in the tree industry, college, cert, cdl, whatever.
2. Certification hopefully gives a common language to communicate with. Reduction cut, branch bark collar, etc. that's very important when communication.
In terms of wages different companies do different things and it depends what you want. If you want to climb the corporate leader apply to Davey, or Bartlett.
We do,a lot of training,,seminars, have new equipment, and demand high quality work. We also create an environment where people are appreciated and safe. We try to pay at the top of the pay scales for our area, and we do offer benefits, but the big companies can offer better benefits typically. I also try to pay my key people as much as I can. So they stay.
Depends on what you want. At the end of the day I didn't get into tree care for the money. You gotta find the right company that works for what you want to do.
My .02$