[ QUOTE ]
Wedges are cool but I work almost exclusively around residences so everything gets a rope.
[/ QUOTE ]
I understand this perspective, as we can often get a rope installed with a throwline, or were already in the tree.
However, I think that this is often based on urban-trained tree folks. I started in forestry work and got lots of wedging training aka "what are ropes for".
What I find is that most people will have one/ two/ three people on a rope to pull over the tree. This means that one/ two/ people are in the direction of the fall (frequently pulled straight, not redirected) and can not be doing other things. Clearly, they should be are outside of the landing zone of the tree, which means longer ropes to lay out, and re-stack/ coil. Maybe getting wet, which then means drying.
This also means that the rope is off the ground and out of the way. Less likely to have it tangle with brush, get cut by a saw, either on the ground or cause it is dangling in front of the face-cut (whether its a top-drop, or ground felling cut).
I would rather have the rope tensioned and tied-off to the base of a tree, this is more protection from it going over backwards than three 200 pound guys pulling. I would rather have the rope tied off, and if the wedging will not tip it, then push downward on the rope, increasing the force (think of 200 pounds of force on a slackline, perpendicular to the slackline. Much increase in force).
So frequently people don't have wedging-faith because of a lack of wedging practice because of working near structures, yet rarely do we set two ropes at 45 degrees (or whatever) to the falling lane/ lay. This would give some more control against side leaners while also pulling toward the lay. Very infrequently does a full-on side rope get set, unless there is a heavy side lean the other way.
I figure that tying out the tensioned rope, then wedging it over can be a way to practice/ build confidence in wedging with a back-up, and reduces the dependence on other workers, leaving them free to do other things away from the lay.
I've been working on reducing my dependence on ground support, like natural crotching some limbs on removals and using stubs in the tree like a POW. They will still need to be untied (unless using some additional tricks) but I can work the hinge better from the tree some times.
Also, I started taking my whole climbline up the tree to reduce the tangles. More weight, but less double work.
My $.02.