Tree trimmers for SaskPower get 'a little crazy'

TMW

Location
OH
Tree trimmers for SaskPower get \'a little crazy\'

Tree trimmers for SaskPower get 'a little crazy' in family's yard

http://www.cbc.ca/canada/saskatchewan/story/2009/06/05/sask-power-tree-trimming-123.html

A Saskatchewan family is criticizing the provincial power utility's practice of tree-trimming, saying crews went overboard on their property.

The contractor for SaskPower responsible for keeping power lines clear of tree branches was recently working in Landis, a small town about 125 kilometres west of Saskatoon. Chad Westgard, a resident of the town, gave the contractor's work crew permission to trim the trees in his father's back yard.

"They were here early [in the morning]," Westgard told CBC News on Friday. "And I came outside, and I seen what they were doing, and I said, 'Stop now. You're getting a little crazy with it'."

The Westgards were expecting some light trimming, similar to what they observed on a neighbour's property, to keep branches away from overhead power lines.

However, they claim the tree cutters removed more than was necessary.

"They went even around the yard, and they cut inside ... far away from the power line," Chad's father, Duane Westgard, told CBC News.

He said it took 60 years for the trees to grow, and now, many of them are gone or chopped down to next to nothing.

"I'm gonna have to take these trees out," Westgard said. "I can't have them falling against my house."

According to officials with SaskPower, tree-trimming is a necessary precaution around power lines. In addition to keeping the trees from enveloping lines, trimming back branches ensures high winds do not break off branches, which could fall into lines.

SaskPower said it would investigate what was done on the Westgard property, but a company spokesman was defending the contractor.

"It's a call the arborists make," said Mike Marsh vice-president of transmission and distribution. "They're professionals in their field, and they look at the species of tree, and they determine how far down the limb they have to bring the trimming. And sometimes ... that trimming does go very close to the ground."

The Westgards said they can't get their trees back, but they will try to get financial compensation from the utility.
 
Re: Tree trimmers for SaskPower get \'a little crazy\'

No surprise there, I know who has the contract and have been told who they hired for labor.

Sask. Power does have a tree nursery and will provide free site appropriate tree for under the lines. I wish Mr. Westgard luck in pursuing compensation!
 
Re: Tree trimmers for SaskPower get \'a little crazy\'

[ QUOTE ]

"They were here early [in the morning]," Westgard told CBC News on Friday. "And I came outside, and I seen what they were doing, and I said, 'Stop now. You're getting a little crazy with it'."

[/ QUOTE ]

Lol that's pretty canuck.
 
Re: Tree trimmers for SaskPower get \'a little crazy\'

In my area of Saskatchewan they have bulldozed 30 meters on either side of the lines. The plan being to do more frequent mowing in the future rather than expensive pruning. What is left though is a slash pile of nice spruce and poplar which could have been firewood if anyone cared and could get off petroleum and electricity. I believe the wild animals will have another obstacle to limit their movement and in about 100 years those piles may decay. And the more frequent mowing before trees regenerate, we'll wait and see but I doubt it. They call it progress.
 
Re: Tree trimmers for SaskPower get \'a little crazy\'

[ QUOTE ]
30 M either side of the line seems excessive. Is it Distribution or Transmission rights of ways being cleared?

[/ QUOTE ]

Depends on the voltage. 30M for 69-115 seems a bit much, but if we are talking 500 line or higher, than thats a different beast.
 
Re: Tree trimmers for SaskPower get \'a little crazy\'

The clearance was done on any rural line which ran through forested land. But we had just had "the storm of the century" and I suspect it was a knee jerk reaction to all the damage. Could of been in the plans though. And although the firewood idea would have been a better use of the wood, I don't imagine the power company wanted any yahoo with a saw cutting along the lines.
 
Re: Tree trimmers for SaskPower get \'a little crazy\'

It's not in the contract and they don't have to deal with it. More wasted resource. Funny how that is, depending on who does the cutting and for what reason. If it's a timber co, then its raw materials; if it's a line clearer then its waste...
 

New threads New posts

Back
Top Bottom