So an update: I just started it up again and sat there the whole time paying attention to the gauges. It seems that if I let it sit and cool down it will start back up just fine and then give it 5-10 minutes and the gauges all start going wonky / vibrating until I hold down that murphy switch.
It almost seems as if the switch is working because if it were not why would everything be fine when when I press it? Maybe I don't understand how a murphy switch works. Anyways, the gauges start going wonky / vibrating and then it starts to shut down when the gauges vibrate enough to hit the shut off point but it is due to them vibrating in the first place. It is almost as if nothing is actually wrong with the machine but something is making the pins on the gauges start to vibrate after 5-10 minutes. I've attached a video to make more sense.
In one of the videos the gauges just start go wonky / vibrate after 5 minutes or so of it running.
In the second video, you can see how the machine has now begun to shut down and I can hold the murphy switch in and it will continue to run fine.
Just figured I'd give some more details. Thanks!