I’m glad @Matias chimed in since he knows Euc like you. As more of an Oakman, I couldn’t tell you what led to the failure, but I will say this…It would probably flatten it
They bigger than they look
I’ve been leaning more and more into aspects of forestry/silviculture in the residential realm. I think in the past I was overly focused on the one tree in front of me.
Remove and replace is often the most appropriate prescription, as the best time to plant a tree is 10 years ago and we don’t need to prolong the inevitable. Financial boundaries can steer away from following that plan, and risk mitigation becomes the game.
This is all a bit fresh as this kind of situation arose about 12 years ago when one of my client’s neighbors had a 20” Silver Maple leader removed on their side of the tree. The writing was on the wall and we developed a R&R plan for the next roughly 10 years beginning with risk mitigation and understory planting. One 3 year interval follow up visit to further reduce and by the next 3 years entry to remove the overstory, the planted trees were well established and framed the space like champs.
Sorry for the long winded reply @davidwyby , but you’ll find the right prescription!























