Tree related work you shouldn't need insurance for?

I know insurance varies, I pay nearly 25k per year.
This gets me general liability, professional liability, commercial auto, inland marine, and workers comp for the two employees.
Workman’s comp is an hourly rate paid to the state here, at ~4.50 per hour/per worker.

Owner operator insurance is cheap. Typically based on estimated gross. I’d have it even if I did less than 10k on the side per year. If it ate too deep into that 10k annual I’d just work an extra day per year to pay for the policy.

It’s really stupid not to have insurance!
Before we closed the other year, I was paying over $70k a year, and that was with excellent workers comp rates. We aren’t back to that level yet, but will be soon. Insurance is expensive, but well worth it. When one of my drivers wrecked a truck and we had to replace it, the insurance company paid the $90,000 for the truck and probably $15,000 towing bill to pull it out of the woods.

You are correct, owner operator insurance is cheap. Around here, you can get a basic landscaper policy for about $500 a year. That’s pocket change in the scheme of things.
 
This thread makes me feel a lot better about paying for insurance.
While I can somewhat agree with @tomstrees on the basis of “ I’m careful, low danger so insurance is just unnecessary”.

There is just too many ways for that to go sideways, many which were pointed out by @Reach . I’m glad to hear you were able to actually use your insurance, and continue to have it too!
 
Adding to this:
Rant warning

This is something that is entirely stupid. I can pay my crew shit wages and run them into the ground which is more likely to trigger a claim. Or I can pay very well work less hours and be more unlikely to have a claim. Yet it cost more in insurance and eats into the overhead more. Thus raising rates to the customer passing on the expenses. This of course generates more revenue to be taxed..::
Rinse and repeat
 
I accept the fact that I'll never be even close benefits paid out with what I pay for insurance (GL, health, auto, etc). But lawyers...unfortunately you can sue for anything and there are some people that feel they are the victim in far too many circumstances.
 
Yeah profit is, dividends are, wages are. Yes misspoke but you get the point right? It’s setup in a way that promotes exploitation of the labor, creating a feedback loop that feeds back into the government.


The idea that liability insurance being based on payroll is a nefarious, stupid ploy to pay more taxes into the government is an ill founded stretch with no proposed recourse to correct the imagined malady… typical for a rant, but who doesn’t enjoy some mental exercise?

Taxes paid as a fraction of profit… Your idea of a feedback loop exploiting labor to feed the government uses a bunch of buzz words that while sounding like a revolution has no meat or foundation. In your flawed premise, the biggest benefactor of the supposed loop is decidedly you with 60-80% of the profit going in your pocket.

What is a more equitable way for an insurance company base their exposure to liability?
 
....

What is a more equitable way for an insurance company base their exposure to liability?
Hours worked. (At least for general liability. Obviously workers Comp is gonna be payroll because if someone is outta work for on the job injury the compensation will be based on their payroll.)

Why hours makes more sense than payroll: if your crews and my crews do the exact same thing every day and I pay my crews $25 per hour but you pay yours $30 per hour does your insurance have more exposure than mine? I don't know, but I'd bet the company with the higher paid crew has a little less because when employees feel treated well (more than money!, but that's a starting place) they operate safer. But the company would be paying more for the same insurance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: evo
I don’t often work by the hour, but I’ve not worked a normal job for $400/hr in years.

Normally we have a Manitou 3060, 416hp 22” chipper, Yanmar SV100, and a 165hp stump grinder on the job.

We’re not set up to do every job by a long shot, so we focus on our strengths. If not for it being occasionally handy and mainly my ego, I’d sell my 92’ lift.
Whoa. That's what I would call a heavy setup. I bet cleanup goes fast!!
 
Hours worked. (At least for general liability. Obviously workers Comp is gonna be payroll because if someone is outta work for on the job injury the compensation will be based on their payroll.)

Why hours makes more sense than payroll: if your crews and my crews do the exact same thing every day and I pay my crews $25 per hour but you pay yours $30 per hour does your insurance have more exposure than mine? I don't know, but I'd bet the company with the higher paid crew has a little less because when employees feel treated well (more than money!, but that's a starting place) they operate safer. But the company would be paying more for the same insurance.
I agree with you completely. The system seems to be backwards. My new liability insurance company bases their premiums on gross sales, I think that is much more sensible than payroll.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ATH
Then you'd get no work, none of the customers will pay those rates unless you are, for example one of the $3K-$4K and up a day aerial tree services around here. Most of those with wood piles either do the work themselves, leave the wood to rot or have it hauled out.
Not putting too fine a point on it here: if you're only bringing in a couple grand a year with that work, let the wood rot. Like has been said so many times here and on previous threads when I have admitted to working without insurance, if you aren't charging enough to do it right, it's probably not worth doing. I now do 99% of my work under other operators licences and insurance, but when I do a solo job, I only do it because it's a friend, and I charge enough that if something goes wrong, the money I make from the job should cover potential damages. I lose more bids this way, but so what?! It was only a few grand a year I was making that way, and I have safer options!!

Oh, and rotten wood turns into soil, so there is nothing being wasted by you not doing the work.
 
Last edited:
I agree with you completely. The system seems to be backwards. My new liability insurance company bases their premiums on gross sales, I think that is much more sensible than payroll.
More sensible IF they look at sales by category. Do you do any consulting? That's somewhere 10% of my annual gross. Should reflect a lower general liability....but possibly more professional liability if those are risk assessments, bit not appraisals or diagnostic services. How about tree planting? That'll be another 10-15%. As long as I'm calling 811, they have very little exposure.
 
More sensible IF they look at sales by category. Do you do any consulting? That's somewhere 10% of my annual gross. Should reflect a lower general liability....but possibly more professional liability if those are risk assessments, bit not appraisals or diagnostic services. How about tree planting? That'll be another 10-15%. As long as I'm calling 811, they have very little exposure.
I agree, that would be nice if they were look at categories. I do not do any consulting, or not enough to count at least. Maybe a few hundred dollars a year at most. No planting either, we refer that out. In house, we do pruning, removals, stump, grinding, and treatments. All of those are similar risk level in my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ATH
There’s good easy money in tree planting. Diggers hotline can be a time suck but have the HO call it in for a dig ticket. And it’s job security.
I agree, it can be profitable, we just don’t usually have time for it during the right times of the year, and that requires me to switch gears from our normal loads on the trucks, and to train the employees to do something they are not accustomed to doing. Unfortunately, that takes all the profit out of it for me.

The dig ticket is easy, we are approved to submit them online through our state now, so I can do one in just a few minutes. We are supposed to do them for stump grinding, but usually don’t unless the homeowner really wants us to. What utility are we really going to hit in the top 6 inches of soil?
 
There’s good easy money in tree planting. Diggers hotline can be a time suck but have the HO call it in for a dig ticket. And it’s job security.
In Ohio the contractor has legal obligation...plus I don't want to show up and see the HO forgot when I show up with trees. Or when the cable company doesn't mark and we cut a cable, need to be the one that called...
 
..,What utility are we really going to hit in the top 6 inches of soil?
Cable. They are always shallow around here.

Electric company stopped by a site this fall "I couldn't get a good tone on that line...but it's just feeding the street lamp. No big deal if you cut it, just let us know." If it wasn't marked and we cut it, we'd be fined. (Didn't hit it, so that's good)

Working with a client who was digging old stumps for us to replant. He popped a gas line that was about 5' away as a root was wrapped around it. $2500 fine. If he called 811, probably still would have popped the line, but no penalty.
 
Cable. They are always shallow around here.

Electric company stopped by a site this fall "I couldn't get a good tone on that line...but it's just feeding the street lamp. No big deal if you cut it, just let us know." If it wasn't marked and we cut it, we'd be fined. (Didn't hit it, so that's good)

Working with a client who was digging old stumps for us to replant. He popped a gas line that was about 5' away as a root was wrapped around it. $2500 fine. If he called 811, probably still would have popped the line, but no penalty.
Comcast lays their cable that shallow around here as well. Problem is, they refuse to mark their cables. They say it is “cheaper to repair one in ten cables than it is to mark all 10.”

When they do mark things, back when I had my landscape companies as well, and we did a lot of digging, we learned they were terribly inaccurate. Never hit a gas line, but we sure dug up enough electric lines and fiber optic lines that were nowhere near where they were supposed to be.
 

New threads New posts

Kask Stihl NORTHEASTERN Arborists Wesspur TreeStuff.com Teufelberger Westminster X-Rigging Teufelberger
Back
Top Bottom