Can you clarify on just what you mean by kerf cut in this situation?
Are there factors that add to the likelihood of the tear below the hinge? I've never seen or heard of this. Is this superficial, as in ripping down the bark and sapwood, or is it across the heartwood as well? Any specific trees that you know of that this is more likely to occur with?
Only once on a removal when I was taking the top off of a tree near a knot, possibly where it had been topped/ broken 20-30 years before, have I had the bark rip down the trunk potentially entering into the lanyard loop. It seemed like the change in the grain contributed to this.
In the negative effects listed in your post, is it due to the hinge not cleanly breaking when the face cut closes, thereby steering it off to the side of the intended lay? How does this affect barberchairing?
Thanks for any thoughts.