Tractor, skid steer, or excavator?

I personally dig my Bobcat E55 with a few attachments. Rigid rotator grapple, forestry drum mulcher, and the small feller buncher head.

Rubber tire options are definitely fantastic for lawns, no doubt. There are ups and downs to everything, but if lawns were never a concern, I would go mini-excavator every time.

IMG_8709.jpegIMG_6398.jpeg
 
If I ever wind up getting an excavator (.....I probably will eventually....I also think they are the best option in my area and for my type of work) that is about the exact size and setup I imagine buying.
 
I personally dig my Bobcat E55 with a few attachments. Rigid rotator grapple, forestry drum mulcher, and the small feller buncher head.

Rubber tire options are definitely fantastic for lawns, no doubt. There are ups and downs to everything, but if lawns were never a concern, I would go mini-excavator every time.

View attachment 97608View attachment 97610
Yo Whip , could you please give us some specs on your attachments. That grapple and feller head are both awesome!
 
Bold. Hope you get returns you would deserve. So many inventors/innovators don't in the arb industry.
It may be a longer row I can actually hoe at this point in my life, but maybe not. I can oly try and see.

It’s not like it would be a high demand item. Maybe build a few a year? Dunno.
 
Seems to be working well for you and that speaks volumes to me!
Part of the trick would be matching them to other machines. I had to add a hydraulic multiplier to my older machine that made the aux circuit toggle between rotate and grab.

My E55 was ordered to spec so I got the 2nd aux circuit which gives me independent rotate and grab functions on the factory joysticks, which is really nice. From there, I use a multiplier in the buncher head to switch the grab function to cut.

Without that factory option, this is all still possible, but perhaps a little convoluted for some. Ideally, another small valve bank would be plumbed into the machine and new joystick handles would run the expanded functions. That kind of luxury can get fairly expensive.

I will say I think my choice in rigid rotators was good…it’s a worm drive unit with a very short build height. This type or rotator has great holding capability compared to other styles. I also made a custom offset coupler to greatly improve geometry for tree work. I’m not digging much at all, as all work is at grade or above, making current boom geometries a bit less than ideal. The smaller the base machine or carrier, the more important these factors are to making it useable in this type of work, yet these factors are still valuable with larger machines. I can speak to this having started with an E26. Proper implement geometry can make or break overall use ability.

The E55 is very capable, and a regular guy can haul it to residential sites without a CDL. That said, and now having my CDL, I do think of 8 to 10 ton sized machines with traditional boom mounting locations over the front mounted swing boom style bit more…almost twice the tonnage of what I have now yet not sized out of residential work.
 
I like my SV100 for being a maximized mini… I still wanted a swing boom for more options in tight areas.

View attachment 97704
I’ve been looking at some older SV100s. I’d like to get the hybrid steel/rubber track setup. It’s a unique sized machine and from there they all seem to make a significant jump in overall size.
 
Is the swing boom the extra point of articulation at the base of the boom? I've heard of that as being very effective when used to feed a chipper.
Yes, it is the extra point of articulation.

I would say that depending on the attachment, the offset can be beneficial, but with a rigid rotating grapple, the offset is basically unnecessary.

My opinion is that the offset just inherently puts the boom in a position where you have less ability to hold things close to the carrier in a vertical position. This also holds true with the drum mulcher when trying to work in confined spaces.

With the boom mounted in a traditional position, you also have greater lifting capability based on stability, making work over the sides more equal to over the blade. This is useful in situations where something heavy is being moved around…like trees and logs. :)
 

New threads New posts

Kask Stihl NORTHEASTERN Arborists Wesspur TreeStuff.com Teufelberger Westminster X-Rigging Teufelberger
Back
Top Bottom