rfwoodvt
New member
- Location
- This side of eternity.
Over the past few years I've been noticing a fair number of Pinus strobus that have basically "up and died" within a short period of time.
Most of the owners said the trees died within 6 months of looking sick. Some said they really hadn't noticed until it just turned brown and died.
All of them have kept thier needles after death.
I myself had one give up the ghost two years ago. I really didn't delve into why but this year I had a Pinus sylvestris pine do the same thing but that took less than 2 months to crap out.
Anyhow, the progression and symptoms are the same and the P. sylvestris looked like a classic pinewood nematode attack. So did my [p] P. strobus[/i]
Here is my quandry. From what I've been able to find P. strobus is resistant to the PWN, yet I am seeing what looks like PWN damage to PS quite frequently.
If a species is resistant, what is a reasonable frequency to see such damage?
If the tree shows classic signs of PWN but it is a "resistant" tree speicies, should I delve further?
Thots?
Most of the owners said the trees died within 6 months of looking sick. Some said they really hadn't noticed until it just turned brown and died.
All of them have kept thier needles after death.
I myself had one give up the ghost two years ago. I really didn't delve into why but this year I had a Pinus sylvestris pine do the same thing but that took less than 2 months to crap out.
Anyhow, the progression and symptoms are the same and the P. sylvestris looked like a classic pinewood nematode attack. So did my [p] P. strobus[/i]
Here is my quandry. From what I've been able to find P. strobus is resistant to the PWN, yet I am seeing what looks like PWN damage to PS quite frequently.
If a species is resistant, what is a reasonable frequency to see such damage?
If the tree shows classic signs of PWN but it is a "resistant" tree speicies, should I delve further?
Thots?