i have YET to find a pair of boots that makes my feet happy. In my life I have tried over 90 pairs of different boots, ranging from expensive, hadmande, to cheap. They either fall apart, or the soles get too flexible, or they suck up water ike a sponge, or the "real" leather is not leather.
For my feet i need a boot that has a NON flexible sole. Boots with ANY sort of flex in the sole hurt my soles. The best boot i have had so far (but was'nt CSA or WCB approved) was a pair of mountaineering boots from Germany that had a 1/2" thick solid oak platform in the sole, from heal to toe. zero flex. uber comfortable i loved those boots. They got stolen though..
Spur climbing in any boot that flexes (even a tiny tiny amount) or where the sole compresses, is excruitatingly painful for a week after. if i climb in iceboots (no flex) its great, but the boots are very heavy.
my next pair of boots will be the VIBERG Tricounis, with caulk soles. Viberg will be custom making the boots and the sole for me, with a 1/8" stainless steel plate running the length of the boot, follwed by the Oak midplate. I'll be paying priemum dollars for it, but at least my feet will be happy.