I started climbing in a Bry-Dan and love it. I have changed companies since then and could not take my Bry-Dan with me but man was it great. I loved the shoulder straps, I could hang upside down and basically limb walk the bottom of these Valley oak branches so that i could really get to the ends... awesome.
I also thought it nice to have the straps for the fact of all the weight of saw, gear, etc. pulling down on my harness. With my current Buckingham saddle it becomes an issue sometimes with all that weight on it. The smaller side D's sound great too. Sometimes while finishing a cut, I hit my elbow right on it.
But I would recommend that saddle for everyday use all the way! Thank you Ed.