Some upset over trees being cut down

TMW

Location
OH
http://abclocal.go.com/wls/story?section=news/local&id=6842895

The landscape in Chicago's Morgan Park community is a little less green.

A homeowner has decided to cut down more than a dozen trees on his property, some more than one-hundred years old. And many of his neighbors are upset with his decision.

One by one, the branches of the trees cut down in on Longwood Drive in the Morgan Park community were being fed into the grinder on Monday afternoon. Nineteen white oak trees - many we are told are over100 years old - were ordered cut down by the owner of the home who no longer wanted them on his property.

Neighbors are stumped over his decision to cut down the trees on this tree lined street.

"I feel sick about it. It's damaging a community asset. It's not just a private property issue. This is a historic neighborhood," said Carla Winterbottom, Morgan Park resident and activist.

According to Willy Whittaker, the owner of the home, the trees were cut down because they blocked his view. He said they were old and they were diseased.

"They were not diseased. I spoke to the arborists who are doing the job. They are visibly upset. They were not deceased. They were erfectly healthy oak trees," said Winterbottom.

Kathleen Tobin of Keeping Beverly Green, a group dedicated to saving trees says there are no laws against property owners cutting down trees. She refers to Mr. T, the Rush Street bouncer turned actor who cut down about 100 oak trees from his estate in Lake Forest in 1987, citing allergies as the reason.

"We have absolutely got to have restrictions on taking down 100 175-year-old oak trees in a community that prizes itself for its heritage of oak trees," said Tobin.
"I think there needs to be some kind of permit or review process before this gets done," said Winterbottom.

Some of the trees on Mr. Whitaker's property were over 175 years old. Neighbors say it is not fair to the community to cut them down.

"I think it would have been nice if they had kept president landscape with the trees although they was old and bent," said Randy Lowe, Longwood Drive resident.

Residents say the street will never be the same now that the trees are gone.
 
bla bla bla, both sides exagerating like always, I'm sure.

If you don't want healthy trees cut down in your neighborhood, then live in a neighborhood that has association rules and everyone in it has to abide by them.

end of story..........
 
Wow!

That is a pretty strong reaction X.

Oh, sure...private property rights...I own them I can do what I want...blah blah blah...

But...who really does 'own' trees?

If there aren't neighborhood covenants would you like to have a house painted purple with black trim? I know a house in Minneapolis owned by an Arctic Cat fanatic and that's his color scheme...flippin' awful! Visual pollution... On and on...

Too bad for the trees and the neighborhood. Good for the company and the sales commission...blood money...pffft!
 
New Treebuzz category

Well Tim, it looks like advocacy should be a new category of topic on the Buzz. Kinda like the TREE Fund, the arborists favorite charity. Saving trees that have been condemned due to their negative perceived qualities having been deemed more important than the beneficial aspects is a service that analytical arborists can offer.

We have a group of neighbors called Save The Trees-Seattle that has called attention to this misguided emphasis that promotes land development regardless of the quality of the urban forest. We now have an audit that shows city services do not rightly consider the beneficial aspects of trees. A proposal to appoint a citizen advisory urban forestry commission has been made by the City Council, and a new tree ordinance is being developed. Check out our non-profit at www.SaveSeattlesTrees.com.

If anybody wants information on how to pay the $50 filing fee to incorporate your group, please let me know at (206) 949-8733.

I'll bet lots of local people have organized to affect the decision making process to save trees that have been condemned without a thought as to their value to the community at large. Lets hear your stories.
 

New threads New posts

Back
Top Bottom