Mick,
I bought my 250 XP for $4500. When I took it into the shop to get the lights repaired two of the other tree guys came in and were totally bugged that they didn't do deal that I got.
I've talked with owners of the 1230s and 1250s. They just don't have the ability that the 250 will.
They told me they would struggle to get tops into the machine. That it would stop on the littlest of things.
$3000 is, $3000 after all. However, over the long haul, you'll really appreciate the pulling power of the 250.
Remember, you're going to be using it day in and day out.
A constant reminder and frustration of having to cut down material to straight pieces just throw it to the chipper would for me be intolerable.
I would rather go below two or three extra days to make the extra two or $3000, and spend the money on the better machine.
However, "2000" hours seems a bit odd. And remember those gauge clusters are super expensive buying them from bandit.
Each one of the gauges will run you a couple hundred dollars. So you might be over $1000 just for the cluster. Keep that in mind.
I have owned 12 chippers over the past 12 years.
The woodchuck chuck and duck- piece of junk, could only chip little three and 4 inch branches, worthless for big material. This machine is really built just for powerline trimming. It's not really good for doing any sort of major removal work.
An eager beaver 290- I bought this machine from pete manke back in 1998 over the phone. It had a gas straight six. This machine was worthless as well. When you would chip a big piece of wood, when the end of the piece got past the rollers, the rollers would slam shut and the chipper would stop. Then it was a total bear to open the rollers back up and pull the peace out. It would take about 45 minutes each time it happened. I really did not like that machine at all.
two bandit 100's- the bandit 100 really chipped better than the 290. Even though there 9 inch machines (actually I think they're 12 inch... but they don't act like it). And it just builds a better machine. It's weird, I don't know the exact physics behind what makes them better, but they're just better.
Three bandit 250xp's- without a doubt, bang for the buck this is the very best chipper that I have ever owned. Yeah, it doesn't eat the big 18 and 20 inch pieces of material like the others, but I didn't pay $40,000 for them either. I bought my first one for 13,000, my second one for 10,000, and I got a screaming deal on the last one for $4500. The nice part about this machine is that my Dodge Durango can tote around. It's super light.
Two bandit 1890's- one of these had weak hydraulic pump so I can't really speak of how well it worked because I don't think I was seeing it at its full performance. However, the other one, a 2004 "hd" model eight material like there was no tomorrow. It only had the four-cylinder 125 hp, but it would suck material in that big gaping hole, and ask for more. I really loved this machine. However I did not love it $17,000 worth of debt compared to $4500 worth of debt. (This chipper was the last one that I owned before the good deal on the 250 XP)
a wc-17- I bought this machine on eBay and never even took delivery on it. I flipped it for the same price, so I can't really speak of its performance.
two morbark hurricane- heavy, well-built, not too many fancy gadgets, and chips like crazy. However, the last model that I had was a 2001 which really lacked down pressure. My 1890 had way more.
Okay, there's the breakdown with my experience of chippers.
Of course this is just a bunch of rambling..... (smile).